The Rutherford – The Best Buffalo Bills Bar in NYC
There are sports bars in New York City—and then there’s The Rutherford. When the Buffalo Bills hit the field, this is where the Bills Mafia gathers in Midtown Manhattan. Located just steps from Madison Square Garden and Penn Station, The Rutherford is your go-to Buffalo Bills Bar in NYC for every game, every play, and every heart-pounding moment.
Whether you’re celebrating a win or shaking off a close loss, you’ll be surrounded by fans who just get it—no explanations needed.
Home for Buffalo Bills Games in Midtown Manhattan
The Rutherford proudly transforms into Bills Country on game day.
Every Sunday, Monday, and Thursday night, our big screens light up with red, white, and blue as fans from all over NYC come together to watch the Bills take the field.
Every Bills game is featured live on multiple HD screens throughout the bar, so you’ll never miss a touchdown, interception, or Hail Mary.
Unlimited Beer & Wings Game Day Special – Because some traditions shouldn’t be limited. Join us for unlimited beer and wings during every Buffalo Bills game. It’s our way of saying: we’re all in this together.
Game Day Energy, New York City Vibe
There’s something about cheering for the Bills in the heart of Manhattan—it just hits different. At The Rutherford, every Bills game is an event, not just a broadcast. From pre-game hype to post-game celebrations, the atmosphere is electric and the camaraderie unmatched. Live DJ and M, with competitions throughout!
Fans gather around tables decked with crispy wings, cold drafts, and classic bar bites, while our bartenders keep the beers flowing and the energy high.
Wings, Beer, and Buffalo Pride
If you’re from Western New York—or wish you were—this is where you’ll feel at home.
We’re keeping the Buffalo tradition alive in NYC with our fan-favorite wings, tossed in that iconic Buffalo sauce. Pair that with endless pints of ice-cold beer, and you’ve got a game day that would make any Bills fan proud.
Enjoy Unlimited Wings and Beers:
Beers: Michelob ultra, Bud Light, KCBC Pils Country, Labatt Blue, Heineken Light, Stella, or Truly Seltzers
Wings: Buffalo (Naturally), Plain
Price: $64.95pp (Whole party must participate)
The Rutherford – Right by MSG & Penn Station
Address: The Rutherford, W 33rd St, New York, NY 10119
Perfectly located near Madison Square Garden and Penn Station, The Rutherford is the Midtown destination for Buffalo Bills fans traveling from all over the city (or straight from the train).
No need to trek to the East Village or uptown—you’ve got the best Bills Bar in NYC right here in Midtown.
Join the Bills Mafia at The Rutherford
This season, skip the search for the perfect Bills bar—you’ve already found it. Get your crew together, grab your jerseys, and head to The Rutherford, the official home of Buffalo Bills fans in Midtown NYC.
Come for the unlimited beer and wings, stay for the Electric Bills atmosphere.
We’ll save you a seat by the screen.
Bills on the big screen
Looking for the top spot to watch Buffalo Bills games? The Rutherford delivers every kickoff, touchdown, and game-winning drive on giant screens with cold drinks, great food, and an electric atmosphere.
Join the Bills Mafia and cheer on Josh Allen and the squad with fellow fans who bring the noise every Sunday. From the regular season to the playoffs, we’ve got you covered.
The Rutherford: Your home for Buffalo Bills football all season long.
