Bills Mafia · Sunday, Monday & Thursday Nights

Buffalo Bills Bar Midtown Manhattan

When the Buffalo Bills hit the field, this is where the Bills Mafia gathers in Midtown Manhattan. Every Sunday, Monday, and Thursday night, our big screens light up with red, white, and blue as fans from all over NYC come together — rooftop views, multiple big screens, and a room full of Buffalo pride just steps from Madison Square Garden and Penn Station.

Every game is an event here, not just a broadcast — a live DJ and hosted competitions run the whole way through, fans pack in around tables of wings and cold drafts, and the bartenders keep both the beer and the energy flowing. Join the Bills Mafia and cheer on Josh Allen and the squad from the regular season through the playoffs.

Book Now Schedule Wings & Beer
Every Bills game, live on the rooftop

Buffalo Bills Schedule

Loading schedule…

Every Bills Sunday, Monday & Thursday

Unlimited Wings & Beer

$64.95 Per Person · Whole Party
Sun · Mon · Thu Game Nights
Buffalo or Plain Wing Sauce

Rooftop views, big screens, and a crowd of Bills Mafia red, white, and blue.

  • Michelob Ultra
  • Bud Light
  • KCBC Pils Country
  • Labatt Blue
  • Heineken Light
  • Stella
  • Truly Seltzers
Book Now
Right by MSG & Penn Station

Find Us on Game Day

This season, skip the search for the perfect Buffalo Bills bar in New York City — you’ve already found it. We’re right by Madison Square Garden and Penn Station, easy to find no matter where you’re coming from — grab your crew, grab your jerseys, and we’ll save you a seat by the screen.

W 33rd St & 8th Av, New York, NY 10119

Get Directions Plan a Group Watch Party

Go Bills

see you on the rooftop.

Bills Mafia, Answered

Buffalo Bills Bar FAQ

Where can I watch Buffalo Bills games in NYC?

The Rutherford, at W 33rd St & 8th Av in Midtown Manhattan, shows every Buffalo Bills game live on the rooftop and on multiple big screens — steps from Madison Square Garden and Penn Station.

Is there a Bills bar near Madison Square Garden?

Yes — The Rutherford sits right by Madison Square Garden and Penn Station, easy to reach from anywhere in New York City.

What's the Bills game day food and drink special?

$64.95 per person gets the whole party unlimited wings (Buffalo or plain) and beer, every Bills Sunday, Monday, and Thursday night.

Can I book a group or watch party for a Bills game?

Yes — The Rutherford's events team sets up group watch parties and private bookings. See the Events page to plan one.